Over the past week, I have read another portion of the book
and am at the halfway point. Journeys
have been made and deaths have occurred in this section. I noticed that the author focused the second
quarter of the novel on the Afghan customs versus the American customs. Amir and his father migrate to the United
States and are living in Freemont, California as U.S. citizens. However, Baba passed away due to lung cancer
shortly after Amir got married to another Afghan, Soraya. Amir and Baba stay true to Afghan customs in
California, which made it easy for them to reconnect with other Afghans in the
area. Throughout this section, how they
view trustworthiness and forgiveness struck me the most as cultural differences. The opinions on these three cultural values
show how difficult it is to assimilate into a new country.
Shortly
after arriving in America, Baba saw how America was not seen as trustworthy as
Afghanistan when writing a check to store clerk to buy fruit. While handing over the check, the clerk asks
for an ID from Baba, which makes Baba explode with rage shouting, “What kind of
a country is this? No one trusts
anybody!” (Hosseini 128). This incident is a great example that
captures the differences in American trust and security. As a country, the United States wants to
ensure that everyone is who he or she says they are and check that with
identification. Although you could be
going to the same store for years, clerks still check identification because
there can be no special treatment for loyalty to a store. This confuses Baba because he is used to the
Afghan lifestyle where everyone trusts everyone and credit cards are made out
of branches, with cuts in the branch to mark transactions. America finds it difficult to trust others
because of the national threats and terrorist attacks on our soil in the past.
The motto
in America for forgiveness is that if you make a mistake, you can do everything
in your power to fix it, and if not, everyone makes mistakes at some point in
their lifetime. “America was
different. America was a river, roaring
along, unmindful of the past. I could
wade into this river, let my sins drown to the bottom, let the waters carry me
someplace far” (Hosseini 136). America
is a clean slate for Amir, letting him remember his wrongdoings in Afghanistan,
but allows him to move on. America is
forgiving of the past, which is necessary for him to make a new lifestyle for
himself in this country. Amir knows that
in Afghan culture, once a sin is committed, the sin stays with you
forever. I think that leaving
Afghanistan and migrating to America was the best decision for Baba and
Amir. Now not only are they safe, but
Amir can finally build the life he wants and become a writer. Amir was struggling a lot with facing Hassan
after knowing what happened to him; Amir needed a fresh start in order to start
this new chapter of his life as a mature adult.
Afghan
moral values when compared to the traditional American values were very
interesting when looking at how all of these values were packaged together to
shape Amir in the novel. Since Amir
successfully connected Afghan and American values together, he is able to be a
traditional Afghan husband, but also is understanding and follows the American
values of his wife being seen as an equal.
The novel’s
connections between Afghanistan and the United States are very interesting and
I am interested in how the rest of the novel turns out. So far so good!
A thoughtful discussion of the cultural differences the book highlights, particularly when it comes to forgiveness.
ReplyDeleteOne thing to remember is that the books takes place before the terrorist attacks we now link to Afghanistan, so while there are issues related to trust in America, the book highlights how they were in place even before 9/11. Imagine how much less trust there would be for Afghans after 9/11.
Thank you so much for the response! I didn't really think about the time of 9/11 and how it links to Amir's narration of Afghanistan, but it makes the picture even clearer about his treatment as he was leaving Afghanistan as well as how he is treated while in America. The phrase said in this section that made this divide clear was when Baba shouted "No one trust anybody!" The ability to trust Afghans became more difficult after the 9/11 attacks. Even recently, it has no longer become about someone's ethnicity when trying to trust individuals, but about their religious beliefs. For example, the San Bernardino attack led the country to become even less trustful. We no longer just look at someone's ethnicity as a threat, but to some Americans, also their religious background.
DeleteI like how you did not simply focus on all differences between Afghanistan and the U.S. but chose to concentrate on incidents including trustworthiness and forgiveness. I agree that America has given Amir a clean slate, but I believe that this is temporary sense of peace and that he will eventually have too seek out some form of closure.
ReplyDeleteThank you Sierra! I think that this sense of peace is part of how he acts with his now wife, Soraya. The reasoning behind this peace could be due to his new environment and Soraya's sense of peace is making him feel at peace as well. I think that in the next section he will need to reach that closure; and that will have to be done by talking to Rahim.
Delete